The current chapter of the Leipzig Trade Fair: For now, a vaccination center is moving into the halls. The hope remains: There will be good times again. Martin Hoferick(29 Jan 21)
The Minister for Culture and Science in NRW has warned that culture must be careful not to always demand a special treatment. The scene should not >move too far out of the social consensus,< she said. What on earth is the offense of the scene? Max Moor(08 Nov 20)
We are an important part of the economic cycle: we pay an unbelievable amount during the year to art shippers, art fairs, construction teams, to the Artists' Social Welfare Fund.... Rupert Pfab, Galerist(28 Apr 20)
They only know entrepreneurs with employees and obviously do not know at all how we work and what we need after we have been banned from the profession. Nadine M.(07 Jun 20)
The digital life, an aid in times of distress, will not be able to replace our need for a home. Not satisfying our thirst for shelter. Carmen-Francesca Banciu(20 Nov 20)
There is a concern that there will be less opportunity to give presents because of fewer celebrations. However, confidence is based on the fact that customers more often choose cheap gift books than expensive skis in times of crisis. Michael Wurmitzer(09 Nov 20)
We don't know yet how long the Corona period will last. If older actors are systematically not cast, this could result in age discrimination. Heinrich Schafmeister(17 Jun 20)
In the Corona crisis we experience a strange recourse to images. But pictures do not help us to understand the situation from a distance, neither in Bergamo nor in New York. Daniel Kehlmann(06 May 20)
What is actually needed in parallel is an instrument for short-time work for the artists. Heike Herold(04 Jul 20)
If I find the measures inconsistent, arbitrary and not effective enough, however, how will the rioters and haters in the web feel? Dorothea Marcus(31 Oct 20)
The Chancellor and the heads of state are obviously interested in making it really bang loudly so that even the last one understands that the summer with its freedoms is over. The theaters are only one of several pawn sacrifices. Georg Kasch(28 Oct 20)
Wouldn't the time be right for a special solidarity payment for the wealthiest in this probably harsh autumn and an impending full lockdown? Herbert Grönemeyer(04 Nov 20)
It is not new that our analog concept of the creative person around the book has become more challenging. But Corona is dramatically accelerating the development here. This poses a considerable problem for us. Ulrich Wellhöfer(02 Apr 20)
In my view, there is no cultural shortage in children's rooms. A free reading by authors brings no added value to entertainment. Salah Naoura(25 Mar 20)
As far as gross value concerned, we have added value that is only surpassed by the automotive industry. We have more than the chemical industry, we have more than the financial service providers. In 2018, we generated in our sector more than 100 billion euros in gross value added. Noam Zur(29 May 20)
What would have to happen? You now have the opportunity to rattle a few cages. Jörg Biesler(02 Aug 20)
Artists give away their work for free on the net. This reinforces the impression that this is a hobby. They like to do it and everybody is allowed to participate. Helmut Mauró(02 May 20)
When we show up, nobody is seeing us. When we don't show up,we won't be missed. Maren Kroymann(14 May 20)
How can the art world react to the fact that the institutions are so geared towards tourism and large exhibitions. Daniel Birnbaum(30 Apr 20)
Just the idea that school classes would follow mathematics lessons in the peace and quiet of a museum for months, receive social studies from Joseph Beuys and discuss history in the stalls of a [...] theater hall - what an outrageous gain. Catrin Lorch(11 Nov 20)
Theaters, opera houses and concert halls have been proven not to be places of infection. Their excessive restriction therefore does not contribute to the containment of the occurrence of infection, and is therefore disproportionate. Deutscher Bühnenverein(27 Oct 20)
However, when the going gets tough, people pretend that self-employment was above all self-realisation and nobody could expect society to take responsibility for it now. Jagoda Marinic(12 Jun 20)
Absurd. There is no meadow, no pub, no shop, no subway and no cabinet as far apart as the Philharmonie. Egbert Tholl(25 Jun 20)
We are also there to hold up the mirror to society and to initiate discussions. But if everyone has to eke out a living with side jobs, there can be no more social criticism in the future. Petra Tobies(08 Aug 20)
A logistical adventure is currently taking place in the rehearsal rooms: routing people with masks to the rooms, then let them play without masks, but with the distances that they must not exceed. Michael Schmitz-Aufterbeck(31 May 20)
[...] first the business life and then we can take care of sports and culture. I find that such a purely populist statement, which is after all said by a prime minister who is one of the leading figures in the management of the Corona crisis. That does pull the plug. Ulrich Khuon(07 Sep 20)
I would like to see a more relaxed view on the risks of life. After all, we don't take away the driving license of every second driver because he is a potential cause of accidents. Matthias Goerne(13 Sep 20)
At the moment my job here in the theater is to actually take care of the inner life. Not mine, but that of the many staff members, because it feels very different than in March, when we were in a phase of the emerging spring [...]. Karin Beier(29 Sep 20)
For freelance musicians, the federal government has made it much easier to apply for basic social care, also known as 'Hartz IV'. But many find it humiliating to go to the job center. Eva Blaskewitz(02 Jun 20)
In 2019 there were almost 800 film releases, this year we might not even get 200, and even worse, we're not getting the films we need to attract an audience. Michael Pawlowski(05 Sep 20)
If so many who work in the private and publicly funded art business can currently survive only with aid packages, something is wrong with the entire system. Something has to change radically here. Iris Dressler(23 May 20)
The true state religion in this country is to have permanent positions. This explains the Corona special regulations and billions in aid. In the case of the self-employed, the state acts as if they themselves are to blame for the lack of orders. Sascha Lobo(09 Dec 20)
Give back culture to the Bavarian people! Unfortunately, State Premier Söder and Minister of Culture and Science Sibler react completely ignorantly and arrogantly. Dr. Axel Schertel(07 Jul 20)
I lose a lot of my potential audience. And as someone who doesn't have a regular readership, that's not the best thing. Jasmin Schreiber(06 Apr 20)
Not hugging, not touching, moving at least one and a half metres away from the neighbour - for people who consciously communicate with their bodies every day, this is a maximum penalty. Dorion Weickmann(12 May 20)
We think all the time, what can we actually do to positively influence the situation and that is frighteningly little. Farin Urlaub, Die Ärzte(23 Oct 20)
Despite the arts sector being the first and worst hit sector, and likely the last to recover, the budget fails to provide a roadmap for the sector based on bold, strategic vision and long-term recovery. Leya Reid(08 Oct 20)
Perhaps the cultural shutdown also comprises some good points, in so far as one can learn to appreciate Benjamin's “unique appearance of a distance as close as it may be”. Unlike kitchen art an aura cannot be simulated by definition »simply at home«. Richard Kämmerlings(27 Apr 20)
We need to enter into resistance. We are going to invade churches, shopping malls, auction houses... and we will put on shows! Samuel Churin(15 Dec 20)
I'm really worried that when we open again, not everyone will be there because people have decided to do something else after this long stretch. Carsten Brosda(11 Feb 21)
The Leipzig Book Fair will be all the more sorely missed this year as a forum and a place of self-exploration for an industry whose identity crisis is becoming increasingly apparent. Helmut Böttiger(29 Jan 21)
And so films are shot all over the republic, with sometimes quite different restrictions ranging from very strict to rather lax. And also with double standards: On the set, we pay attention to distances. After the shooting is over, we meet in the beer garden without masks. Jörg Seewald(16 Jul 20)
Nobody has to come up with investigations anymore, really. Or do they after all? Exactly with this? With the investigation of what happens and what remains when a community experiences a collective heartbreak, a general disaster? Simone Buchholz(28 Oct 20)
Singing in closed rooms is prohibited, period. Maria Ossowski(29 Jun 20)
Nobody is completely submerged, swimming against the current is exhausting, but sometimes clever thoughts go through your head. Sabine Seifert(29 Jul 20)
The whole discussion is mined. One can actually only make a mistake at the moment when one tries to make justified legitimate criticism of the measures. Ulrike Guérot(24 Apr 21)
While some are looking for the vaccine and others are discussing whether it is actually a good thing, we at least provide in theatre a vaccine against mental incrustation and aberration. Nicolas Stemann(25 May 20)
It is the core challenge of publishers and at the same time the magic of our work to bring the market and the art together. It is a deeply social process. Tom Kraushaar(27 Mar 20)
I surmise that this time, if it ever comes to an end, if we can overcome this pandemic, we will all emerge traumatized. I don't think it's something you can simply terminate. Lars Eidinger(18 Nov 20)
The employer's contribution to the artists' social security fund KSK is paid not only by the state, but also by the companies in the art and culture industry with their duties. Since the cultural industry has come to a standstill, these are now missing, and the existence of the artists' social security fund is endangered. Brigitte Werneburg(09 Nov 20)
The balance sheet is of course devastating. After almost six months of lockdown, three months of really bad business, we have a 70 percent drop in sales. Christine Berg(20 Dec 20)
We want to write a manifesto to the president, all of us, thousands of Marseillians, to make it clear that there is no reason at all to sacrifice culture in this situation. Benoît Payan(30 Jan 21)
Our work stands for diversity and freedom of opinion, for knowledge and pluralism, for emotional, intellectual and cultural exchange, innovation in thinking and the intellectual creation of new - and sometimes better - worlds. Netzwerk Autorenrechte(05 Jun 20)
I would just like to see that the contribution that we make to the containment of Covid-19 is not rendered moot by keeping, say, the ski resorts open. Nicolas Stemann(22 Dec 20)
Art is like air. When it's there and it's good, we don't perceive it. If it were gone, we would notice it. Stephanie Lexer(31 May 20)
A final climax, a bright final chord - and then? No cheering. No bravos. Only dead silence after a sensationally good concert, a strong plea for New Music and an appeal for more music in lonely times. And I am close to tears. Rattle still quietly says "Bless you. Thank you so much." - and releases you into silence. Jens Lehmann(13 Mar 20)
It’s hard not to feel abandoned by American society as an arts worker. Georgina Pazcoguin(23 Sep 20)
There is no protection for workers in the United States, which is why there are mass layoffs in the art world, in galleries and museums. Vincenzo de Bellis(03 Jun 20)
But if the theaters are really interested in acting as the social laboratory as which they like to see themselves, then they could use the pandemic stop as a pause for reflection to negotiate their own future. Björn Bicker(20 Jul 20)
So much creative energy has been pent up everywhere during the pandemic, and now it's time to put it to good use! Gerald Mertens(02 Feb 21)
Is it inconceivable to put artists in a position to bridge the next eight, nine, maybe even twelve months without slipping into total depression because of unintentional and undeserved misery? Anne-Sophie Mutter [u.a.](19 Apr 20)
The combination of streaming services and pandemic actually presents a unique danger situation. Netflix's stock price skyrocketed while movie theatres are on artificial respiration. Andreas Busche(28 Dec 20)
What is needed are the open spaces of art that make exchange and reflection possible - including on how Corona is changing our society. Barbara Mundel(22 Oct 20)
That is strange. I was just at the ticket office, and people don't want to give their tickets back at all, they prefer to see the schedule for December already. They push it into the theater, and yet I think there is a weaning effect in the long run. Christian Stückl(02 Nov 20)
I think that even if the shields were to be released in the fall and the audience would willingly think them away, that would not be possible. I see what I see. With masks it would be funny, you hardly see the actor, you don't really hear him. Jan Bosse(26 May 20)
The protection of life is - in the truest sense of the word - not a killer argument to legitimise arbitrary, limitless restrictions on other freedoms. Christian Hillgruber(09 Dec 20)
Never has the book, never has literature been so valuable, so important, as a place of escape, as a retreat, as a source of new, different thoughts - and for a long time the symptoms of economic crisis have not been as threatening as in 2020. Gerrit Bartels(08 Oct 20)
Now it's about not complaining, but still offering theater in all its facets - if you let us. At the moment we are allowed to do so, and now we have to show that it is right. Uwe Lohr(13 Sep 20)
It would be ironic if TV streaming services were to make lockdown millions while the very source of our acting, producing, writing and directing talent pool was allowed to die. Sam Mendes(05 Jun 20)
The crisis reveals that many self-employed people do not have a business model that can cope with any change from a normal situation. [...] The attitude that crisis and old-age provision for the creative people is a problem for later has no future. Dieter Haselbach, Pius Knüsel(27 Jul 20)
[...] Wednesday's package of federal and state resolutions, on the other hand, pushes culture into the annex, which lists the closure orders still in force, between "restaurants, bars, clubs" and "prostitution facilities", between beer and brothels. Andreas Kilb(18 Apr 20)
You can fly in a full plane, travel in a bus, but people don't trust us to follow the rules and instead people celebrate in the park. Erik Kühn(02 Oct 20)
Anyone who doubts, for which there are good scientific reasons, the necessity and effectiveness of the authoritarian government measures to combat the pandemic is treated as if he wants people to die. Andreas Rosenfelder(25 Apr 21)
For me, this will be the first Christmas in 20 years without performances, without children's laughter and without mulled wine with colleagues. Kerstin Dathe(26 Nov 20)
Art dealers must hope that [...] they will not already be suffering the cathartic side effects of the pandemic. This would not only be an economic damage, but also a cultural damage. Museums do not have the monopoly on the basic supply of art. Marcus Woeller(19 Apr 20)
To shape better policies, national and subnational governments need more and better evidence on the economic and social impact of cultural and creative sectors. OECD(07 Sep 20)
It was difficult to get a view, to see or to read corona-distant, even non-corona topics, but with the first easings this is slowly changing again. But now Corona literature snapshots? Gerrit Bartels(06 May 20)
The film industry in Austria stands for an economic output of approximately 1.4 billion. We are now running for our economic life and for this survival a state default liability related to Corona is essential. Oliver Auspitz(16 May 20)
What really worries me is that in public discourse, especially in the leading media, [...] very, very little art and culture has appeared. That means both the question: How are you? How do you work? And also: How do you, dear artists, think about this situation? What is your contribution? Stephan Behrmann(02 Oct 20)
Currently we are all experiencing a shortage of the big movies. But perhaps this is an opportunity for the European film industry, but also for Europe as a whole: to establish a new form of communication about films. Carlo Chatrian(17 Sep 20)
I am not given enough thought about the economic consequences of these step-by-step decisions. The entire sector is insecure, paralyzed, there is no basic timetable for what is possible under what conditions and when. Julius Frack(15 May 20)
The pandemic has not only negatively impacted the creative sector in Africa, but it has also exposed its shortcomings. Ribio Nzeza Bunketi Buse(28 Dec 20)
Artists and cultural institutions have no lobby and had to serve as "soft targets" for measures that politicians had not dared to implement elsewhere. Nicolas Freund(05 Jul 20)
If it were purchases, it would be good, if it were other aids, it is at least welcome. I see it positively and also find it great that Mrs. Grütters is directing money towards galleries. But as I said, purchases would be sustainable. Rupert Pfab(27 Sep 20)
I have seldom seen the audience so grateful, everyone was incredibly happy that there are cultural offers again, and it became clear: literature is a nutrient. Heike Strecker(19 Jun 20)
I think it is also simply too rigid how culture is treated. Gunter Gebauer(24 Oct 20)
I know famous accompanying musicians, who usually stand with the biggest German stars on the biggest stages of our country, who are now sitting at the supermarket checkout. Heinz Rudolf Kunze(17 Sep 20)
The precarious conditions under which so many freelancers work in the cultural sector must be reconsidered in future funding policy. Ulrike Groos(07 Jul 20)
"United We Stream" won't help us to rescue the clubs. Just for Berlin, 10 million per month are needed for personnel, rent, leasing contracts, etc. to save the venues. Lutz Leichsenring(28 May 20)
There will also be a new appreciation for how precious each seat is. Because then there are fewer houses in the country that play, fewer performances, fewer places. Theater tickets will be the hot shit in Berlin! Oliver Reese(23 May 20)
Now that the Book Fair has been subjected to this ordeal, it is clear what this unique, crazy, sensory event has always been: always too crowded, always too loud, always too expensive, always a risk. But at the same time, it is also a fascinating place to negotiate spirit and goods [...]. Sandra Kegel(04 Jul 20)
At the moment there are mainly panic reactions. I don't see any issues negotiated yet. Cornelia Fiedler(22 May 20)
Has the fear of the virus, in the words of Erich Fromm, long since mutated into a »fear of freedom«? René Schlott(08 Feb 21)
Now everyone is surprised that the great cheers about the reopened museums are missing. Many visitors are still sceptical. Many museums had hoped for completely different numbers than they can now present. Wolfgang Ullrich(14 Jul 20)
Artists, especially those who are not permanently employed, have to improvise permanently, have to do things they are not qualified for, they all almost become entrepreneurs as independent artists. Julian Nida-Rümelin(18 Oct 20)
In music, the audience is part of the communication. Clapping, reacting, empathizing is a crucial part of a live experience. It is very difficult to reproduce this digitally via livestream. Dr. Pop(08 May 20)
The criteria for evaluating art in the digital world are missing. Just because something is done digitally doesn't mean it is the hot shit. Anika Meier(02 Jun 20)
In houses like Baden-Baden and the Berlin Philharmonic, the air conditioning is just as good, and the economic hardship is just as great. If airplanes are allowed to be packed, then so are the concert halls. This requires equal treatment. Reinhard J. Brembeck(22 May 20)
Why do we need the cinema? [...] It is about experiencing the increasingly rare protected offline space. Somewhere we have to come back to ourselves, be unreachable and relocate ourselves in our bodies, in the presence of aliveness. Edgar Reitz(04 Jun 20)
The Corona crisis remains the great art obstacle to classical music. In the USA everything lies idle until January. In Paris, everything is falling apart anyway. In Germany a kind of classical allotment garden is blooming. Manuel Brug(20 Jun 20)
Creative industries will lose an estimated 2.7 million jobs and more than $150 billion in sales of goods and services, amounting to nearly a third of creative-industry jobs and almost 10% of annual sales. Richard Florida & Michael Seman(11 Aug 20)
Grönemeyer considers cultural workers to be civil servants of a public enterprise on behalf of the nation's services for the public. Rainer Hank(15 Nov 20)
There is much debate about why this disease now? What logic is behind it, what morality? Towards the end of your book and after reading Albert Camus' »The Plague«, Matteo comes to the conclusion that there is no morality that can be drawn from such epidemics. Christoph Leibold(19 Jul 20)
For everything that is not subsidized in the field of classical music, the prospects look extremely dismal at the moment. Karsten Witt(08 May 20)
If there was ever a time that the world needed artists, it is now. In the aftermath of the virus, when the world is rebuilding itself, the cities have to step up. Hans Ulrich Obrist(05 May 20)
Nevertheless, artists should not be allowed to commit themselves to the role of the poor creative in the quiet closet. You should occasionally make it clear to your audience that good art is a scarce good that costs something. Elke Buhr(08 Apr 20)
So we need more fear-free discourse, which is obviously not easy in the face of Corona. That's one of the lessons we should learn from #allesdichtmachen. Markus Gabriel(26 Apr 21)
So far there is not a single proven infection in a theater [...]. In this respect, this is not at all a place that is suitable to meet the rising incidence value. Marc Grandmontagne(15 Oct 20)
The tone in the social networks is becoming increasingly bitter. After all, private aid initiatives have formed. Eva-Maria Magel(22 Apr 20)
With little funding, a lot could be done in the freelance sector - but there is a catch: This would officially recognize that there is a two-tier system in classical music. Frederik Hanssen(16 Nov 20)
Being profitable would be the wrong expression. But in fact, we're getting there. We receive support from the Hamburg Department of Culture and therefore we keep afloat. Corny Littmann(13 Aug 20)
It is true that the event industry as a whole needs urgent help, survival aid. The distress is enormous. Tom Koperek(22 Jun 20)
If we assume that more and more rich people want to buy social status, charisma, and appreciation with art, there are no sales worries for the art markets, rather supply problems. Christian Herchenröder(17 Dec 20)
When I hear this relentlessly rigorous Karl Lauterbach, I would like to recommend Juli Zeh's novel »Corpus Delicti« and a little grain of the author's sense of freedom. Arno Orzessek(25 May 20)
Galleries such as Pace, Gagosian (which furloughed its part-time staffers in April), and David Zwirner (which laid off nearly 40 employees this month) all took in between $2 million and $5 million. (07 Jul 20)
Then, however, Hesse, as the federal pioneer, opened up before all the other states again at once. Announced on Friday it was fact on Monday. Nobody could get up that fast. Theatres are tankers, complex, interlinked systems. Manuel Brug(20 May 20)
The plans for the next season had to be completely revised and reorganized in the last weeks. But we have succeeded [...] in developing new visions for this coming, extraordinary season. Oliver Reese(19 Jul 20)
These freelance photographers, along with many other freelancers, are probably the poorest pigs in the corona crisis. Yes, there is a lot to photograph. But the commissions are missing. Steffen Grimberg(07 May 20)
It is about raising awareness that the artistic values ??that are created are more than aesthetics. They are basically life-sustaining spaces of reflection and scope for society as a whole. Ulrich Khuon(19 Apr 20)
Of course I would like us to [...] sing again soon. But I also know that when we sing, when we speak, aerosol clouds are created. And I think it's important that this is now being scientifically investigated. Kerstin Rosenfeldt(03 Jul 20)
The answer to the virus can only be that charity goes viral. And if that sounds too pious to someone, he simply calls it solidarity, which is contagious. Pastor Sieghard Wilm(01 Nov 20)
This almost sounds like a self-abandonment of classical book culture. Corona doesn't seem to be the only virus the industry is suffering from. If in the end a virus called anxiety causes even greater damage, that would be fatal. Paul Jandl(17 Jul 20)
The past few years have already seen pushback against the art world’s gross socio-economic inequities [...]. Even before Covid, it was high time for a reset. Jane Kallir(22 Jun 20)
The play that our stages have to play right now is called: »Struggle for survival« – not only of artists, but of an enlightened and open society [...]. Axel Brüggemann(27 Oct 20)
I just think things out: I have looked at the plans from the WHO, from the Federal Government. Then I researched everywhere and made a story out of it, and now that story is about to become reality. Klaus-Peter Wolf(06 Mar 20)
We don't let autumn take us away. Books are more important than ever. Joe Lendle(12 May 20)
We were closed with restaurants and bars, but they’ve been open for a while, and it’s actually safer to be in a theater because you keep your mask on. Catherine Russell(26 Oct 20)
Will the ticket inspectors measure the temperature of visitors in the future? Jörg Häntzschel(19 May 20)
And then I worry about all my colleagues and friends who work as freelancers. Nobody knows what should happen to them when concerts simply no longer take place. Geoffry Wharton(12 Mar 20)
In 2020, we still had the income from 2019, in which Corona played no role at all. But that means that in 2021 we will have the full loss of the German Performing Rights Society (GEMA) payment, because in 2020 only a fraction of the concerts were performed. Christiane Albiez(03 Feb 21)
This creative industry most recently achieved a value added of 253 billion euros, accounting for 4.4 percent of the EU's gross domestic product. In short, it ranks as "a European heavyweight. Stefan Weiss(26 Jan 21)
Rather, the bitter impression that the significance of culture is so low, despite your lip service in recent months, that the first solution to the rising number of infections seems to be: »Is this art? Then let's get rid of it!« GMD- und Chefdirigent*innenkonferenz(02 Nov 20)
There won't be any viewers crowding into a sold-out house close to each other and glowing with joy, and that's not because of the quality of the program. Nicolas Stemann(11 May 20)
A general strike up to a hunger strike would literally show how much the culture, namely the creative people, are starved. Peter Weibel(28 Apr 20)
The fact that critical contemporary art of all things leaves a lousy carbon footprint is deeply absurd. A new museum culture could slow down the carousel, if only because in future either the works travel or the viewers do. Not both. Catrin Lorch(05 Jul 20)
It is incomprehensible to us why it is possible to keep DIY stores, car showrooms and other stores open, but museums, which have the same or more generous areas for corona-friendly public traffic, are closed. Deutsche Museumsdirektoren(01 Nov 20)
That's the perversion of the whole story. We are not a swimming center. It's not like we can close in one day and on December 1st we open again and the audience is back. Louwrens Langevoort(29 Oct 20)
The infection rate that we now see going up has nothing to do with civilized events like concerts, cabaret, theater and that drives the artists crazy! Volkmar Halbleib(28 Sep 20)
We all hoped so much that business would restart in autumn, but now no one can come from China or America. And the Spanish or French collectors will also drop out. Esther Schipper(11 Sep 20)
It is painful to have to witness this unequal treatment and, despite requests and pleas, not to be heard by the appropriate corridors of power. Anne-Sophie Mutter(20 Oct 20)
I had actually written another book. When the virus came, he snuck in there relatively quickly. Then I thought, what does he want here. He wanted to get in there. Lola Randl(28 Aug 20)
The Corona virus crisis revealed clearly that very many artists are not safeguarded and that it is more than ever necessary for artists to be able to insure themselves against unemployment, for example. Caroline Richards(17 Jun 20)
It is the very own task of the management of a state theater to guarantee the operation of the play in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations. Angela Dorn(26 Sep 20)
It's hard to remember a time when culture in this country was considered so dangerous that it had to be locked away and banned from public space. Roman Bucheli(30 Dec 20)
The aids that have been applied are all very unfortunate because they mostly do not apply at all to the professional model of freelance actors, freelance artists. Jochen Schölch(29 Dec 20)
Instead of giving up the current season under political constraint or in anticipatory obedience, the task is to finally pull the strings again. Marco Frei, Christian Wildhagen(01 May 20)
As soon as it becomes the rule to override fundamental constitutional rights at will with every new challenge, democracy is damaged. Dieter Hallervorden(09 Nov 20)
»The show must go on, no matter how difficult it is.« It's an overused expression, but I think it's the essence of theater. Hideki Noda(05 Mar 20)
If we are honest, the question of what costs what is no longer an issue. [...] The thing that is really depressing the population at the moment is that we have these limitations when it comes to social contacts. Olaf Zimmermann(26 Oct 20)
In doing so, it is time to give the small, local events as the ecological garden prior to intensive agriculture, [...] the individual artist prior to the culture industry employee the focus and empathy they have long lost. Karl-Werner Joerg(26 Dec 20)
Today, doubt is permissible, even desirable, and basically also the driving force of liberal societies to move forward by questioning what is already there. Ralf Schuler(25 Apr 21)
In Austria, the cultural nation, the following obviously applies: politicians and cultural bureaucracies are waiting for suggestions, organizers are waiting for guidelines. One could despair of this sluggishness if there weren't folk musicians, church musicians and counterexamples. Hedwig Kainberger(02 Jun 20)
The 2020 budget is more uncertain than any budget I have ever experienced. Claudia Rütsche(10 Aug 20)
[...] perhaps that will be the essence of after-pandemic criticism. More personal, more to the point, more empathetic, more open and less formulaic. Philip Kennicott(29 Nov 20)
The frustration and with freelancers also the fear are nevertheless understandable. But culture needs better ideas about itself. Better arguments for what it is there for. And for what it is not. Culture, for example, is not there for everyone. Tobi Müller(29 Oct 20)
It's a curious situation we have right now. For example, if I live as an artist in Hamburg, then I'm lucky. If I live a few kilometres away in Lower Saxony, then I've had bad luck. Olaf Zimmermann(12 Jun 20)
We are already in our fourth month. There is no longer any hope for the goodwill of the real estate industry. Lutz Leichsenring(20 Jul 20)
During the Frankfurt Book Fair, there is always such a rapid rise in the level of debates in German media - and this is another reason why the silence this week is so spooky. Felix Stephan(17 Oct 20)
Events of the ten signing Houses of Literature were attended by around 70,000 visitors last year with around 1,400 dates with approximately 3,000 contributors. Die zehn Häuser der Literatur(11 May 20)
Nevertheless, culture is indispensable, and therein lies its paradox: it is always both a total luxury product and an elementary medium in which a community agrees on what it considers important or unimportant Dirk Peitz(05 Jun 20)
We had a certainty that concerts would take place, that trips could be made, that tours would take place [...]. All that is really really shaken, shattered, you could say. Marie König(15 Feb 21)
It's interesting that we keep an eye on the theatre repertoire business when we all have time for completely different artistic activities and formats. Nicolas Stemann(29 Jan 21)
You may call it kitschy or embarrassingly pathetic: But the soul of many people needs some solace in the pre-Christmas season. Solace with music, with concerts, with theaters, with musicals, with art. Culture helps to survive the most emotionally challenging time of the year. Maria Ossowski(26 Nov 20)
Both, we have lost many jobs. So we had an idea: There's an issue out there, we have time, we're off now. Thomas Victor(23 May 20)
Many people no longer want to accept the situation. If it continues, the consequences for human coexistence and social peace will be almost incalculable. Alexander Skipis(23 Feb 21)
The bottom line is that "Neustart Kultur" [Restart Culture] is nevertheless only a small program, a drop in the ocean, on which especially private artists are threatened with thirst. Anne Sailer(24 Aug 20)
Well. Does culture suddenly no longer have to explain that it is not a luxury that you only have to worry about once survival is assured? Kolja Reichert(25 Apr 20)
I could imagine that Frankfurt would do well to think about it right now: How can this trade fair be changed? I think it would be a mistake to simply assume that you can carry on as usual. Elisabeth Ruge(13 Oct 20)
If we high-frequency culture users were a political party, we would fail at the five per cent hurdle in every election. Peter Grabowski(01 Feb 21)
The real and the beautiful is often created under precarious conditions. So far, hardly anyone has been interested in this. This should make the audience and the press blush of embarrassment.. Gero Schließ(30 May 20)
This year is a complete write-off, and if it continues like this, then at least for me I can no longer work as a freelance writer, if no money comes in through book sales and readings, then I have no income. Michael Stavarič(25 Sep 20)
This is a different mode, but also a chance to present art in a completely different and contemporary way to art aficionados. Wolfgang Ullrich(17 Mar 20)
On top of all that, the Arts Council’s funding requirements now place “relevance” over “excellence” as the highest goal of British theater. Helen Lewis(12 May 20)
Our cultural life was not in the best condition even before the pandemic [...]. I fear that their long-term consequences are not yet clear to us in the least. The great [...] event culture will rise again. But what will become of all the more specific initiatives, venues, artists, less mainstream? Andreas Staier(04 Nov 20)
If we want to survive this crisis reasonably in the cultural sector, then there must be additional subsidies for a specific culture fund. Olaf Zimmermann(25 May 20)
It is true that the many millions [...] are also intended to »award new contracts to freelancers and solo self-employed persons«, as the »Neustart« programme states. It remains to be seen whether this measure will really account for the lion's share in the end or whether it will be invested in Plexiglas panes for everyone. Ingo Arend(08 Jul 20)
When I look at how solo artists are doing: There are many of them who have no income and have to live with short-term support again and again [...], then I think we should perhaps use this break to think a little bit about the future. Amelie Deuflhard(05 Nov 20)
Recently, Jens Spahn also warned against events. He meant private celebrations, but he said: events. After that our advance ticket sales collapsed because people thought it was too dangerous to go to the theatre. Wiebke Eymess(23 Sep 20)
Everything that is fun and innovative will then disappear. Or it will be bought up by big companies and streamlined until all events look the same. Julia Gudzent(21 Sep 20)
On the other hand, the Book Fair is a place of lived freedom of opinion and publication. This is also an important pillar of the Frankfurt Book Fair and this pillar will be there. Alexander Skipis(08 Sep 20)
While permanent employees would receive short-time work compensation, the loss of earnings of artists would be "completely negated". In many cases, at least. Karin Finkenzeller(14 Jun 20)
The decision affects the wrong people, it touche them to the quick, it is destructive, because culture is not relevant to the system, this term from the financial crisis is only annoying. Culture is relevant to existence, it is relevant to life. Maria Ossowski(29 Oct 20)
The situation in the cultural sector has been
described and discussed in numerous interviews, corona diaries,
comments and reports in the past few weeks. Our annotated
of currently 193 sources
gathers voices from different sectors and media.
This creates a picture of the cultural landscape in crisis,
whose temporal transformation can be explored interactively
via a dedicated
Ein Jahr ohne Werke . Was es für das Musikleben bedeutet, wenn Verlage um ihr Überleben kämpfen A year without pieces . What it means for musical life when publishing houses fight for their survival
Music publishers play an important role in the cultural ecosystem. Not only do they promote the work of composers, but they also produce well thought-out sheet music in individual parts, ensure good binding quality of the sheet music and produce new editions of historical works. To do this, they conduct study of sources and work with scientific precision. The publishers therefore generate income not only from the sale of sheet music, but above all from the lending of scores of mostly copyrighted works to orchestras and choirs. The rental fees are made up of various facto rs such as the length and instrumentation of the work, the number of performances and seats available for sale. Last year, the turnover from rental fees for music publishers collapsed by up to 80 per cent. In addition to lending fees, publishers and rights holders also lost income from distributions by the German Performing Rights Society (GEMA) and foreign collecting societies as well as the German Music Edition Society (VG Musikedition). Since royalties are usually only paid out in the following year, the loss of income will not be felt until 2021. Publishers who specialise in choral music are also particularly affected, as it is not foreseeable here when rehearsals can be resumed. In the lockdown, only the purchase of individual parts and chamber music with small ensembles boomed. Henle-Verlag, which serves this segment with an app, among other things, is the only publishing house that recorded an increase in turnover in 2020.
As long as there is no planning security in the cultural sector, the sale and rental of sheet music will not increase. The staff of the publishing houses are therefore currently on short-time work and at the same time working flat out to offer works with a small line-up.
Many publishers are currently falling through the cracks of the aid payments because they are either too small or too big. The Neustart Kultur programme can compensate for turnover losses from the rental sector, but only 30 per cent of the lost turnover from April to November 2020, against which aid already received, such as short-time allowance, must be offset. So in the end, the aid is just a drop in the ocean.Read MoreRead Less
Theater in Sachsen-Anhalt bleiben dicht: »Das ist eine Katastrophe« . Corona-Beschränkungen werden verlängert Theatres in Saxony-Anhalt remain closed: »This is a catastrophe« . Corona restrictions are extended
by Luca Deutschländer (26 Nov 2020) Original source: MDR
Cultural workers across the country are frustrated: Lockdown light will be extended into December as well. Janek Liebetruth, independent director and artistic director as well as chairman of the State Centre for Independent Theatre in Saxony-Anhalt sums up the significance of the further closure: »This is a catastrophe«. For theatres in particular, December is the month with the highest turnover. The houses can hardly compensate for the loss of income. Actress Kerstin Dathe, who works in puppet theatre, would have had about 30 performances until Christmas. Wo rries about the future and, above all, the question of whether the state-promised aid will actually take effect are on the minds of the cultural workers. It is uncertain when they will be allowed to perform again. Optimism is increasingly difficult in this situation.
Liebetruth demands that the economic losses suffered by cultural workers be compensated. Programmes like »Neustart Kultur« have the task of preventing a cultural death by offering a perspective for the coming year. What the cultural sector also needs is planning security, because only this can alleviate the frustration somewhat.Read MoreRead Less
In the business section of the FAZ, Herbert Grönemeyer's suggestion to millionaires in Germany for a solidarity contribution in the Corona crisis is critically examined. Already the reasoning does not convince the journalist Rainer Hank. To pay a contribution for the victims of the crisis solely because of family resemblance is not a conclusive argument. In addition, one has to consider, the musician is quoted as saying, that 75 percent of the previous year's turnover for the month of November is not enough to support the artists. Only a permanent monthly ba sic income can get them through the crisis.
Is an artist like Grönemeyer, who is certainly one of the Corona profiteers because of the royalties for streamed songs, allowed to rise to the position of »lawyer for the disenfranchised«? Especially since the profits are likely to continue even after the crisis. Aren't artists suffering in the pandemic rather from the fact that they cannot perform their art in front of an audience? Shouldn't we therefore stop stylizing art and artists as victims of the pandemic and ask the rich to pay for it? Doesn't this turn cultural workers into a "special-purpose and employment society of the nation", a subdivision of the public service for which the state has to provide?
Looking at the political decisions of the last few months, cultural workers are not only protected by compensation payments from Corona Aid, but also have a lobbyist in the government in the person of Monika Grütters. Tax money for culture is permanently secured. And, according to Hank's argumentation, more than 50 percent of it is borne by the rich. It is therefore not possible to ask them to pay once again.
If the creative artists claim more and more state for themselves, then they regard it as "artist's pension fund". This contradicts the idea of the artistic avant-garde, which propagated an entrepreneurial existence of the artist. For this reason, artists should do without lawyers like Herbert Grönemeyer, who, instead of emphasizing creativity, ingenuity and curiosity, degrades the creative industry to a "public fun industry".
Even though Hank is quite agreeable when he emphasizes that there are winners of the pandemic in the cultural industry as well, it should be remembered that Grönemeyer is not concerned with himself when he calls for the support of the rich. He speaks for the many cultural service providers, e.g. light, sound and event technicians, concert organizers, caterers,....., who have lost their income for months and whose reserves have been used up after 8 months of pandemic. A flourishing industry, which normally does not need any support from the state, but was robbed of its income by the prohibition to work and now needs bridging assistance.Read MoreRead Less
Kunst und Care-Arbeit . Fragwürdige Juryentscheidung Art and Care Work . Questionable jury decision
by Brigitte Werneburg (09 Nov 2020) Original source: taz
The Neustart Kultur program also offers scholarships for artists* with children under 7 years of age. The awarding was carried out by the Stiftung Kunstfonds, which also awards annual project scholarships. The benchmark - artistic quality in a nationwide comparison - also applied to the awarding of the scholarships in this special program of the German State Minister of Culture. Now the outcry is great, because more men than women were awarded this scholarship, although more women than men applied. Brigitte Werneburg, editor of the newspaper taz, asks if the awarding of the scholarships is now an expression of the fact that gender-equitable distribution of tasks has already been introduced in the visual arts. This does not seem to be the case when you have a look at the number of applications, in which women are far ahead with 60 percent. The feedback from the Stiftung Kunstfonds was disappointing for many, as the foundation referred to its statutes and the standard of artistic quality, since the grants awarded are not economic subsidies but project funding.
This raises the question of why women artists cannot compete with their male colleagues in terms of quality and whether the fact that one has a child under 7 years of age is an artistic criterion. According to the analysis of the taz article, the Kunstfonds Bonn Foundation does not seem suitable to award the scholarships within the framework of the rescue program Neustart Kultur, since they are now explicitly intended as economic aid.
However, the concluding considerations of the article are particularly worthy of consideration. Artists currently need economic aid. After all, they are not unemployed, but are engaged in gainful activity, which, however, is not permitted on the market at present. Hartz IV is in this situation no adequate offer - not only because the artists are getting into a bureaucratic wheelwork, in which they must attack their old age provision, participate in further training offers and must accept job offers. Much more important is that they are thus excluded from the artists' social security fund (KSK). This unique German system - in which the artists contribute like employees to health and pension insurance, while the employers' contributions are paid by art and culture companies and the state - is fundamentally endangered in the crisis, because when art and culture facilities are closed, there is no income.Read MoreRead Less
An independent theater group, two art students and a small club were interviewed by Felicitas Boeselager for her feature about the independent scene during the Corona crisis in Bremen. What all actors are sharing is the joy of being able to offer events again. The audience at all events was also enthusiastic and grateful to finally be able to experience culture again. The independent scene in Bremen is closely connected by the pandemic, mutual support and exchange about new formats is highly appreciated by those affected. Nevertheless, all of the actors are currently una ble to make ends meet without public funding for culture.
Stephan Behrmann, freelance actor and dramaturge as well as spokesman for the »Alliance of Liberal Arts«, emphasizes that cultural funding in Bremen has been good for both the solo self-employed and the independent scene. However, he complains that the aid did not work so well in all federal states. He considers current scholarship programs that finance the artists' work on projects in an open-ended way to be good. He also rates the support provided by the "Neustart Kultur" program positively - even if one billion does not really seem sufficient considering the size of the industry. Whether the money actually helps the individual artists cannot be predicted at the moment - especially since the administrative effort involved in awarding grants is quite high. How many »silent deaths«, i.e. artists who have looked for a job in another branch, are to be registered, is currently not yet foreseeable. The situation will not improve in the next few years either. Since the municipalities are very much shaken, they cannot afford to support culture. Behrmann therefore considers it an inevitable consequence that the federal government will help out.
The Secretary of State for Culture Monika Grütters is going to provide 16 million Euros to support the galleries in the Neustart Kultur program. Only a part of this money will be used for purchases, whereas the larger part of the support will be used to support the work of galleries in the exhibition business, but also in the field of digitization. The Düsseldorf gallery owner Rupert Pfab is not convinced by the strategy of Monika Grütters. If galleries are to be supported in the current crisis, a reduction in the VAT rate would have the greatest effect. O verall, he considers purchases for the federal art collection to be sustainable. The works would go to museums and other public institutions, which would not only benefit the galleries and artists, but also the general public to whom these works are made accessible. The gallery owner, on the other hand, does not understand why the Federal Purchasing Commission can also buy directly from the artists, as this would circumvent the galleries as an important institution of the art market.Read MoreRead Less
»Es muss etwas passieren. Sonst gehen alle pleite« . Live-Konzerte »Something has to happen. Otherwise everyone goes bankrupt« . Live-concerts
by Daniel Gerhardt (21 Sep 2020) Original source: Die Zeit
While alternative concepts have been developed for other event formats in recent months, the organizers of pop shows are hoping for 2021. The event calendar is already overflowing - but as long as it is not clear whether major events will be feasible again, the organizers are hardly selling any tickets. One problem that the organizers of pop events have had to contend with in recent months has been the ignorance of politicians. Not only the high turnover of the industry, but also its everyday life was completely unfamiliar to many politicians. The fact that support is ne eded here to protect companies from insolvency during the ban on employment has only slowly reached the decision-makers. The support program Neustart Kultur now provides support for music clubs and concert venues, as well as for other members of the event industry, but it seems that the great club and organizer death can hardly be stopped. The consequence? A few large companies will survive the crisis and then events will be streamlined according to a concept. The fun, members of the industry fear, will fall by the wayside, unusual formats will no longer have a chance.
Meanwhile, the industry alliance #AlarmstufeRot draws attention to the situation of the organizers and formulates demands. At a demonstration on September 9th, attention was drawn to the situation of the industry. Many people symbolically put off their shirts in front of the Reichstag - yet here, too, the organizers were polarized: "Every action with which it seeks help could at the same time contribute to prolonging the pandemic."
Wir sind ein Ökosystem . Krise des Kunstmarkts We are an eco system . Crisis of the art market
by Deborah Schamoni, Esther Schipper, Catrin Lorch (11 Sep 2020) Original source: Süddeutsche Zeitung
With the exception of Art Cologne, all major art fairs have been cancelled in 2020. On the occasion of the traditional gallery tours, which open the cultural autumn in Berlin, Cologne, Düsseldorf and Munich, gallery owners Esther Schipper and Deborah Schamoni are talking about the state of the industry in Corona Autumn.
The art trade is not down, but the situation is serious. Whereas international collectors traditionally attended the gallery openings in the fall, they are now largely attended by a local audience. With the collectors, not only is there a lack of income, but the concentration on local business also leads to a complete breakdown of the exchange at fairs. Whether the time left for written contacts can compensate for this will be seen in the near future. The gallery owners agree, however, that the losses cannot be compensated for by a virtual presence - be it their own homepage or the pages set up by the trade fairs. Although it would be possible to sell works by well-known artists, the newcomers have little chance of attracting attention.
On the other hand, the gallery owners are well aware that the art market will have to change in the coming years. Climate change and Corona will become a task for the art market in the coming months and years - even if the gallery owners have to admit that their artists have so far shown little consideration for the climate.
It is still uncertain whether the galleries can really be helped by government support. At the very least, this is an appreciation of the galleries' work. Although they view the funds earmarked for purchases in the Neustart Kultur program positively, they see a reduction in VAT on sales as a guarantee for the kind of sales boom the industry currently needs.Read MoreRead Less
Große Säle, wenig Plätze: Lohnt sich das ganze Theater? . Corona-Schutzbedingungen Large halls, few seats: Is the whole theater worth it? . Corona protection conditions
by Marc Grandmontagne, Anne Schneider, Karin Fischer (05 Sep 2020) Original source: Deutschlandfunk
The format "Streitkultur" at the German radio station Deutschlandfunk juxtaposes two opposing positions, which are represented in the dialogue. The aim is to give listeners the opportunity to examine a complex topic from different angles and then form their own opinions. The question of the current situation of the theaters in Germany offered little potential for debate for the two guests of the program - Anne Schneider, managing director of the Federal Association of the Free Performing Arts, theater director and festival organizer, and Marc Grandmontagne, man aging director of the German Stage Association (Deutscher Bühnenverein). Both agreed that the German theaters need to close ranks at the moment in order to jointly point out their situation and maintain public support.
The discussion thus offered insights into the current situation at the theaters. The demand of the Bühnenverein to allow the cast to follow the chessboard pattern in the theaters, since the danger of infection is demonstrably very low at cultural events with fixed seats, was also presented, as was the plight of the privately run houses. The funds to be distributed within the framework of the Neustart Kultur program will mainly benefit the non-publicly run institutions - however, many program areas have not yet been advertised, since the allocation of funds and the budgetary review of their use still have to be clarified.
Marc Grandmontagne pointed out that one should not be mistaken about the fact that Corona has hardly created any new problems, but rather acts as a catalyst that has brought to light the precarious conditions in many theaters and venues. The situation will not become any easier in the coming years when the public budgets are empty. Nevertheless, one must not forget that culture is a central task of the state. Public institutions such as day-care centers, swimming pools or municipal theaters must not be played off against each other because they are all important for society, its development and cohesion. In addition, no budget can be consolidated at the expense of culture. Rather, the potential that these facilities offer should be used and even unusual approaches should be pursued to shape the future.Read MoreRead Less
The film industry is suffering from the Corona crisis. Above all, German cinema operators do not see how they can maintain their program offerings in the long term. Michael Pawlowski, co-partner of the Filmpalast Group, reports a 50 percent drop in visitors in North Rhine-Westphalia. In federal states with stricter visitor regulations - in NRW only one seat has to be vacated - the decline is even more serious. This means that cinema operations are currently being run from reserves, as the revenues are not sufficient to cover them.
This is the situation that 68 med ium-sized, family-run movie theaters have to address in an open letter to Monika Grütters. The cinema operators need financial support and a relaxation of the hygiene rules. Since the movie theaters are well ventilated and the visitors do not speak during the screening, the risk of infection is lower in the cinema than in the office, according to a study by the Hermann Rietschel Institute of the Technical University of Berlin.
But it is not only the rules of distance that make life difficult for cinema operators. Film distributors are currently holding back on film releases because the number of visitors is currently not very attractive.
Although the German Minister of State for Culture has already released funds to support cinemas, these funds are tied to conversion, modernization and equipment measures and are therefore not helping to save the cinemas in the current liquidity squeeze.
In Bavaria, there is currently an aid program in place that compensates cinema operators for every visitor they have less than last year. In the other federal states, this model is seen as an opportunity to at least cover the fixed costs of the cinemas and prevent a cinema from dying out.Read MoreRead Less
The signet of facing arts joining the faces of STORM.
Facing arts is a non-profi project. Feel free to support it and get in touch with us!
Facing arts is a projet by STORM.
STORM is an acronym playing with the initials by Miriam Seidler & Tim Otto Roth,
who are hit both by the Corona crisis. Dr. Miriam Seidler is a scholar in German literature and currently works as specialist
in public relations. Dr. Tim Otto Roth is a scholar in art and science history and works as a conceptual artist and composer.
He is known for his huge projects in public space, cooperations with leading scientific institutions and his immersive sound and
light installations. Miriam and Tim collaborate regularly for years. With facing arts they reaslize their first common art project.
You find more informatin on both initiators on www.miriamseidler.de
Special thanks to
Paco Croket for the tag cloud programming!
Getting in touch
Get in touch
Write an email to
or use the following form to contact us:
The content of this website has been carefully prepared and reviewed. However, it does not guarantee the accuracy,
completeness or quality of the information provided, or that it is up-to-date. Liability claims against the publisher
in respect of material or immaterial damage caused by the use or non-use of the information offered or by inaccurate
or incomplete information are in principle ruled out provided that there is no provable culpable intent or gross
negligence on the institute's part.
The publisher reserves the right to alter, amend or delete parts of the site or the entire offering, or to cease
publication, without prior notice.
Where the publisher provides direct or indirect references (i.e. links) to external websites, it is liable only
if the publisher has precise knowledge of the content and if it is technically possible and reasonable for it
to prevent use in the event that they contain unlawful content.
The publisher expressly states that the linked websites had no illegal content when the links were set up. It
has no influence whatsoever on the current and future design of the linked sites and hereby distances itself
expressly from any alterations to the content that were made after the links to those sites were set up.
The Publisher is not responsible for the content, availability, correctness or accuracy of the linked sites
or of the offerings, links or advertisements therein. It is not liable for illegal, incorrect or incomplete
content or in particular for damages arising from the use or non-use of the information provided on linked sites.
In all publications, the publisher endeavours to comply with applicable copyrights. If, in spite of this,
an infringement of copyright should occur, the publisher will after notification remove the relevant object
from its publication or indicate the appropriate copyright. All brand names and trademarks mentioned within
the Internet offering that are possibly protected by third parties are without limitation subject to the
provisions of the law on trademarks and related signs and the property rights of the registered owners.
The mere fact that they have been mentioned should not be taken to mean that trademarks are not protected
by third-party rights.
The use of the internet pages of www.facingscience.net is possible without any indication of personal data;
however, if a data subject wants to use the contact form or image upload form of our website, processing of personal data could
become necessary. If the processing of personal data is necessary and there is no statutory basis for such
processing, we generally obtain consent from the data subject.